Passing
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Pass Completions | B. Brown | 122 | 2000 |
| Pass Attempts | B. Brown | 241 | 2000 |
| Passing Yardage | B. Brown | 1,731 | 2000 |
| Touchdown Passes | B. Brown | 20 | 2000 |
| Passing Pct. | Z. Broner | 65.2 | 2013 |
| Fewest Interceptions | Z. Broner | 1 | 2013 |
| PAT Passes | J. Copulos | 6 | 1981 |
Rushing
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Carries | C. Millien | 184 | 2000 |
| Yards Rushing (9 games) | C. Millien | 1,064 | 1999 |
| Yards Rushing (7 games) | J. Morgan | 1,034 | 2023 |
| Yards Rushing (6 games) | J. Chambers | 986 | 2016 |
| Yards Per Carry | C. Benson | 9.8 | 2006 |
| Rushing Touchdowns | J. Chambers | 16 | 2016 |
Receiving
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Receptions | A. Weinstein | 35 | 2003 |
| Yards Receiving | A. Weinstein | 649 | 2003 |
| Average Per Catch | M. Lincoln | 22.15 | 2025 |
| Touchdown Receptions | R. Siegel | 7 | 2000 |
| PAT Receptions | S. Clark | 7 | 1982 |
Offensive Totals & Scoring
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Total Offense | B. Brown | 1,831 | 2000 |
| Touchdowns Scored | C. Benson | 16 | 2006 |
| PAT's | S. Clark | 7 | 1982 |
| Points | C. Benson | 104 | 2006 |
| Points (6) | J. Chambers | 104 | 2016 |
Defensive Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Tackles | W. Gilmore | 64 | 1998 |
| Unassisted Tackles | J. Henderson | 32 | 2016 |
| Assists | A. Stewart | 36 | 2024 |
| Sacks | A. Schlesinger | 12 | 1983 |
| Interceptions / Fumbles | B. Duick | 6 | 2004 |
| Safties | J. Schaeffer | 1 | 1981 |
| Plays Less than 4 yards | W. Gilmore | 53 | 1998 |
| Hits | W. Gilmore | 122 | 1998 |
| Defensive Points | W. Gilmore | 297 | 1998 |
Kicking Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| PAT Kicks | J. Henderson | 13 | 2016 |
| Most FG | E. Ilgar | 2 | 2023 |
Return Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Year |
|---|
| Punt Return Yardage | B. Vallimarescu | 389 | 2012 |
| Punt Return Average | B. Vallimarescu | 35.5 | 2012 |
| Punt Returns | A. Millman | 13 | 1983 |
| Kick Off Return Yardage | B. Vallimarescu | 365 | 2012 |
| Kick Return Average | B. Vallimarescu | 33.2 | 1981 |
| Kick Off Returns | A. Millman | 11 | 1983 |
Passing
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Pass Completions | S. Alberts | 27 | LI Lutheran | 2002 |
| Pass Attempts | S. Alberts | 42 | Brunswick | 2003 |
| Passing Yardage | S. Alberts | 420 | LI Lutheran | 2002 |
| Passing Pct. | Z. Broner | 87.5 | NYMA | 2013 |
| Longest Pass | A. Karen to J. Davis | 99 | Rye CDS | 2024 |
| Touchdown Passes | B. Spector | 4 | St. Lukes | 1982 |
Rushing
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Carries | S. McKissic | 31 | Englewood | 1984 |
| Yards Rushing | Z. Kleinhandler | 314 | South Kent | 2001 |
| Yards Per Carry | C. Benson | 33 | Harvey | 2006 |
| Longest Run | J. Chambers | 89 | Harvey | 2014 |
| Rushing Touchdowns | J. Chambers | 4 | Englewood | 2016 |
Receiving
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Receptions | J. Davis | 10 | Moristown Beard | 2025 |
| Yards Receiving | A. Weinstein | 171 | Fieldston | 2003 |
| Touchdown Receptions | C. Prather | 3 | South Kent | 1983 |
Total Offense & Scoring
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Total Offense | S. Alberts | 401 | LI Lutheran | 2002 |
| Touchdowns Scored | J. Chambers | 5 | Englewood | 2016 |
| Points | J. Chambers | 30 | Englewood | 2016 |
Defensive Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Tackles | B. Metzger | 23 | LI Lutheran | 1992 |
| Unassisted Tackles | B. Franzese | 11 | Forman | 2014 |
| Assists | A. Stewart | 12 | Rye CDS | 2024 |
| Sacks | M. Keden | 5 | Rye | 1981 |
| Interceptions | B. Vallimarescu | 3 | Horace Mann | 2012 |
| Interception Return (yds) | H. Smul | 67 | NYMA | 2012 |
| Safties | J. Schaeffer | 1 | Englewood | 1981 |
| Hits | B. Metzger | 25 | LI Lutheran | 1992 |
| Plays Less than 4 yards | Z. Aarons | 17 | LI Lutheran | 2000 |
| Defensive Points | Z. Aarons | 62 | LI Lutheran | 2000 |
Kicking Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| PAT's | R. Sharan | 2 | Englewood | 1980 |
| PAT Kicks | J. Henderson | 4 | Harvey | 2016 |
| Longest FG | J. Henderson | 37 | Newark | 2016 |
Return Records
| Record | Record Holder | Value | Opponent | Year |
|---|
| Punt Return Yardage | B. Vallimarescu | 99 | Forman | 2012 |
| Longest Punt Return | B. Vallimarescu | 90 | Harvey | 2012 |
| Kickoff Return Yardage | A. Weinstein | 119 | Fieldston | 2003 |
| Longest Kickoff Return | A. Weinstein | 84 | LI Lutheran | 2001 |